August 18, 2014

Rusney Castillo and An Ever More Complicated Outfield Picture



MLBTR’s been contradictory today on where the Phils’ stand in the Rusney Castillo sweepstakes. Early in the day Jim Salisbury reported that insiders thought the Phils were down on Castillo. A few hours later, George A. King of the New York Post reported that the Phils were considered the likeliest landing spot by the self-same insiders. If nothing else, at least everyone agrees that the Phils are in on Castillo, right? That’s a step in the right direction for a club that’s got a reputation for being passive in the international market. Baby steps for an organization defined by its traditionalism.

 It’s hard not to see why the Phils would be in love with idea of Rusney Castillo: As much as I am a fan of Ben Revere (hereafter to be referred to as “Benji”, under penalty of being yapped at) and am an appreciator of his skills, he could be improved on as an everyday centerfielder. And Castillo tends to be profiled as Benji-Like, But Better: The same kind of plus to plus-plus speed and contact-oriented plate approach, but with better outfield instincts and legit gap power. Even if he’s unable to reach his ceiling, his floor is (probably) as a fourth outfielder, and his being a competent defender would almost certainly make him better than John Mayberry, Grady Sizemore, and the 2014 Edition of Domonic Brown. (Whether that’s worth a 6/$50MM deal is something else entirely, especially for a 27 year-old who’s never played a day of affiliated ball.)

But, as indicated above, we do have something of a crowded outfield for a team without any true standout outfield talent. At present, on the 25-man roster, we have Marlon Byrd, Grady Sizemore, Domonic Brown, Benji, and the namesake of this blog, Babe Ruf. Plus an honorable mention to John Mayberry, who’s currently on the DL but would otherwise be with the big club. With rosters set to expand, we could potentially also be adding Aaron Altherr and/or Kelly Dugan to the mix. So, crowded outfield is crowded, as my web-going peers would say. And Castillo would make finding playing time in September even more difficult.

The off-season promises to potentially clear some of the logjam if Castillo is signed, as Grady Sizemore’s a free agent while Dom Brown and John Mayberry are prime non-tender candidates. (Though if Dom were to be non-tendered, it’s almost assuredly because of an expectation to resign him for even less than the pittance of a raise he'll get in arbitration.) Benji will probably be tendered, while Byrd’s guaranteed deal means he’ll be back unless he’s traded. (Which is a possibility that is being discounted, lest the confounding variables spiral out of control.) And The Babe will continue to make the league-minimum as he continues his long trek to getting paid, if he’s with the big club at all. This is all complicated by the front office is murmuring about being interested in bringing Grady Sizemore next year. All that said, it’s a reasonably safe assumption that the odd-man out is John Mayberry, as Rusney Castillo would obviate what little logic there is to continuing to retain Mayberry.

Which would likely give us an OF mix next season of Castillo, Sizemore, Byrd, Brown, Benji, Ruf, Dugan, and Altherr on the 40-man roster. Dugan and Altherr, though, don’t pose serious threats to crack the Opening Day 2015 roster, as Altherr (and his .286 OBP) will probably be doing another tour of AA while Dugan’s hit enough to warrant a start next year with the Iron Pigs. As Castillo and Byrd would be here on the biggest guaranteed deals (and would probably be the best all-around OFs), they could be counted on to be penciled in to be the starting CF and RF, respectively. Benji probably gets slotted in as the fourth outfielder, late-inning defensive sub, and pinch runner. (Unless the Phils feel like being particularly analytical and want to run Benji out there at LF, where his elite defense would provide enough surplus value to cover his atypical positional offense.) Which leaves Sizemore, Brown, and Ruf fighting for LF and a bench spot. Ideally, it’d be as simple as going with the homegrown talent and not bringing Sizemore back.

But as this is the club that justifies playing Sizemore at the expense of Ruf and Dom because it wants to win games in late August and September while fifteen games under .500, I get the sneaking suspicion that The Babe will still be viewed as the first guy to be sent down to AAA when roster space is needed. (That he still has multiple options, while Dom does not, merely makes that a point of disagreement about his ceiling versus being utterly illogical.) Perhaps the club surprises and meets my minimal expectations of competency, leaving us with an Opening Day 2015 outfield of Ruf/Castillo/Byrd, with Benji and Dom on the bench. (Or your combination of Benji or Dom in for Ruf at LF.)

Of course, that assumes the Phils sign Rusney Castillo. If they don’t, the OF logjam is still going to need addressed this off-season, and the potential combinations of free agents and non-roster Spring Training invitees are intriguing. A subject I’ll probably tackle after the Castillo sweepstakes is done. 

Probably.

It's Alive! ALIIIIIIVE!

Another new Phillies blog joins the world. Cue the dramatic thunderclaps and maniacal cackling!

Actually, belay that. This season's already been cartoonish enough without my adding to it.